Sunday, March 29, 2026

King Jehu of Israel must have made a significant mark on ancient history

 

 


by

 Damien F. Mackey

  

The Sinai commission to the prophet Elijah (1 Kings 19:15-17):

Then the Lord said to [Elijah], ‘Go, return on your way to the wilderness of Damascus; when you arrive, you shall anoint Hazael as king over Aram [Syria]. Also you shall anoint Jehu son of Nimshi as king over Israel; and you shall anoint Elisha son of Shaphat of Abel-meholah as prophet in your place. Whoever escapes from the sword of Hazael, Jehu shall kill; and whoever escapes from the sword of Jehu, Elisha shall kill …’.

 

Here I shall be most interested in seeking to learn whether the influence of this divinely-chosen triumvirate had actually extended beyond Syro-Israel.

In other words, can we enlarge any of these three characters, Hazael, Jehu, Elisha, through biblical and/or secular alter egos?

 

I believe that we surely can.

 

Indeed, Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky had already ‘enlarged’ Hazael by identifying him with El Amarna’s [EA’s] Aziru, a presumed son of Abdi-ashirta, the latter being identified by Dr. Velikovsky, in turn, as the biblical Syrian potentate, Ben-Hadad I (Ages in Chaos, I, 1952).

Now, I have argued that this:

 

Ben-Hadad I was a true master-king

 

(21) Ben-Hadad I was a true master-king

 

Thus, Hazael/Aziru must subsequently have taken control of a mighty kingdom!

 

Jehu is less easy to pin down. In the Scriptures he bursts on to the scene in bloody violence, and he, for a time, takes centre stage. But he seems to fade out just as quickly, despite his having reigned over Israel for a substantial period of 28 years.

 

As far as I am aware, Dr. Velikovsky did not propose any EA identification for Jehu.

 

Jehu’s name fails to make it even into the famous Tel Dan Stele, wherein deeds that are associated with him in the Scriptures are attributed to his military partner, the Syrian Hazael: The Tel Dan Inscription - Bible Odyssey

 

“The name of the king who commissioned this inscription is not preserved. However, based on the historical content of the inscription and information from Mesopotamian (cuneiform) and biblical sources, the most convincing conclusion is that the king of Damascus (Syria) known as Hazael commissioned it in the ninth century B.C.E., after he had usurped the throne of Damascus from Ben Hadad (2Kgs 8:15). Hazael subsequently formed an alliance (1Kgs 19:17) with King Jehu of Israel (reigned 843–815 B.C.E.), who was also a usurper. Therefore, it comes as no surprise that the biblical account (2Kgs 9) states that Jehu of Israel slew King Jehoram of Israel (reigned 849–843 B.C.E.) and King Ahaziah of Judah (reigned 843 B.C.E.), whereas the Tel Dan Inscription attributes these royal assassinations to Hazael.  That is, these two usurpers were working together and so both could legitimately claim to have been responsible for the coup de grace. …”.

 

Where the name of King Jehu of Israel is definitely thought to have turned up in an historical record is in the famous Black Obelisk of the Assyrian king, Shalmaneser III, who claimed to have received tribute from Ia-ui-a, son of Omri.

 

But objections to that standard identification have been raised:

 

For one, the name Ia-ui-a does not refer unequivocally to Jehu, but could be applicable to other, similar Israelite names.

 

Secondly, why would Jehu be designated as a son of Omri, if it was the Omri/Ahab dynasty that this king of Israel had spent every ounce of his energy wiping out?

 

And, thirdly, my own contribution (towards a revision of history) is that Shalmaneser so-called III actually reigned about a century after Jehu:

 

Shalmaneser III not of the El Amarna EA era

 

(21) Shalmaneser III not of the El Amarna EA era

 

A potential biblical alter ego for Jehu, so I had thought - without ever having been able to be conclusive about it - was as Zimri king of Israel. I had once written:

 

But, to conclude Zimri, who must not be regarded as a mere flash in the pan,

a substantial and probably necessary alter ego for this Zimri could be as the aggressive

Jehu, king of Israel, whom Queen Jezebel actually calls: ‘O, Zimri, murderer of your

master’. (2 Kings 9:31). Whilst Jezebel’s statement is considered to be a mocking

reference back to an earlier regicide, to Zimri, she may, perhaps, simply be calling the

present regicide, Jehu, by another name, Zimri (or by his nickname).

 

More recently, however, I have chosen to steer clear of that idea.

In fact, I have only just recalled (I had completely forgotten it) that my original idea – which I am now beginning to favour again – was that Zimri was the same as Nimshi, the grandfather of Jehu.

I shall be coming back to that below.

 

It was in my university thesis (2007) that I really set out to establish King Jehu of Israel as an historical figure of immense significance. But, as I badly overcooked certain things in that particular thesis, as recalled with regret in my article:

 

Damien F. Mackey’s A Tale of Two Theses

 

(21) Damien F. Mackey's A Tale of Two Theses

 

and as my attempted reconstruction of Jehu was at the centre of much of this jumble, I would abandon for almost two decades any serious efforts thus to enlarge Jehu.

 

Now (29th March, 2026: Palm Sunday) I feel emboldened to resume what I had begun in that thesis, whilst hopefully avoiding the pitfalls into which I had then stumbled.

 

I want to reconsider here what I had pursued rather too eagerly in my thesis, that Jehu was, beyond the confines of Israel, none other than Horemheb.

 

To sum up so far

 

As far as I am aware, Dr. Velikovsky did not propose any EA identification for Jehu.

           

Biblically

 

For a king who reigned for 28 years, there is an incompleteness in the biblical biography of Jehu.

Once I had thought that it could, perhaps, be supplemented by - but only meagrely - the very brief biblical account of Zimri. That consideration I now reject.

 

            Historically

 

The activities of King Jehu of Israel are recorded in the Tel Dan inscription without Jehu being actually named therein – the credit apparently going to his Syrian partner.

And I personally think that we must discount any notion that Jehu is being referred to in the much later (my estimation) Black Obelisk of king Shalmaneser of Assyria.

 

Not over much to take out in all of that!

 

What about Jehu as Horemheb?

 

Jehu in many ways is a good fit for Horemheb

 

Let us follow through some relevant portions of what I wrote about Jehu in my thesis (Volume One, Chapter 4).

 

Tammi Schneider, in “Did King Jehu Kill His Own Family?”

(Home > Magazines > BAR > January/February 1995),

 

will provide the interesting information that: “Jehu is the only king of Israel to have his grandfather’s name listed in his patronymic”:

 

…. A clue: In the Hebrew Bible, Jehu is called “Jehu son of Jehoshaphat son of

Nimshi” (2 Kings 9:2, 14).

Jehu is the only king of Israel to have his grandfather’s name listed in his patronymic. Why? Traditional explanations would suffice were it not for the Assyrian references.

These explanations usually suggest that Jehu’s father was not as well known in the community as his grandfather, or that Nimshi is a clan name whose meaning has been lost over the centuries.

Another explanation is that Jehu’s grandfather’s name is included to show that Jehu’s father was not King Jehoshaphat of Judah, Jehu’s contemporary.

 

…. that her explanation above has its problems is indicated by the three points that she will now outline:

 

Although the foregoing explanations are consistent with Biblical accounts, they face some significant problems: (1) There is no other Biblical reference to a person named Nimshi, so that he was probably not all that well known; (2) the name “Nimshi” appears as a personal name on a Samarian ostracon, making it unlikely that the name referred to a clan; (3) not only are grandfathers’ names never listed in the patronymics of Israelite kings, but other Israelite kings who usurped the throne, such as Zimri and Omri, have no patronymics at all! ….

 

The Sinai commission, quoted at the beginning of this article, introduces a new triumvirate whom Elijah (or his designated disciples) will anoint for the purpose of instigating a radical purge of Baalism.

 

We find that, peculiarly:

 

Firstly, Hazael’s father is not even named;  

Secondly, Jehu’s father is named differently from how he is named in 2 Kings 9:2.

Thirdly, Elisha’s father is given virtually the same name, Shaphat [i.e. Eli- or Jeho-shaphat], as was given to Jehu’s father, Jeho-shaphat, in 2 Kings.

 

Now here is what I had earlier thought about Nimshi.

 

The reason that Jehu’s grandfather, Nimshi, is given precedence over Jehu’s father, Jehoshaphat, is I believe because this Nimshi may actually have been, for the briefest possible time, likewise a king of Israel.

Queen Jezebel had actually addressed Jehu as ‘Zimri, murderer of your master’ (2 Kings 9:31); Zimri being a commander of the chariotry who had slain king Elah of Israel and had then become king of Israel himself for a mere seven days, before being in turn overthrown by Omri (cf. 1 Kings 16:9-10, 15, 17-18). Nimshi, I suspect, was the same as this Zimri, and hence Jezebel was making a clear point, just prior to her violent death, that Jehu was a conspirator against the crown just as his grandfather had been. 

 

This would explain, at least, why Jehu is graced with having his grandfather included in his patronymic - Nimshi (Zimri) had been a King of Israel.

Moreover, he had been, just as Jehu had now become, a regicide.

 

Continuing with my thesis:

 

Jehoram [of Judah], who had initially slain his own brothers, was fortunate enough to have died before the fiery wrath that was Jehu was unleashed upon the House of Ahab and the worshippers of Baal. The dark era of Ahab and Jezebel, wrote [Philip] Mauro with reference to 2 Kings:[1]

 

... was brought to a bloody end by a ministry of judgment executed by the hand of Jehu. He made a thorough work of it, slaying Joram (Jehoram) and his mother Jezebel (2 Kings 9:21-37), and the seventy sons of Ahab (10:1-7) and “all that remained of the house of Ahab … until he left him none remaining” (10:11).

 

Moreover, when Jehu came to Samaria: “… he slew all that remained unto Ahab in Samaria, till he had destroyed him, according to the saying of the Lord which He spake to Elijah” (10:17). And finally, he executed the vengeance of God upon the priests and worshippers of Baal (10:19-27)”.

 

Jezebel mentioned above by Mauro … I identified in her EA guise … as Baalat-neše (Sumerian: NIN.UR.MAH.MESH) ….

 

This was how Jehu fulfilled his part of the Sinai commission. Though, as we are going to learn in Chapter 10, his radical and violent reform was not confined to Syro-Palestine, but also involved Egypt …. For there Jehu will be identified as Horemheb, the reformer, whose Horus name contained the Egyptian verb, seped, “a technical term describing the process of putting things in order …”.[2] And I should like to venture a parallel between the Egyptian seped and the Hebrew shaphat (שָׁפַט), found in the names of the father of both Elisha and Jehu. In Chapter 10 I shall go so far as to describe the Sinai commissioned triumvirate as ‘shaphat-police’; a kind of military police with a penchant for legalized reform.

 

But what were Hazael and Elisha doing while Jehu was so busy bloodying his chariot?

 

Well Hazael was doing exactly what Jehu was doing. Though the Bible, by way of narration, attributes the extermination of the House of Ahab entirely to Jehu, Hazael himself claimed the credit for it in the Tell Dan inscription, at least according to Finkelstein and Silberman:[3]

 

… the “House of David” inscription, part of a black basalt monument, found broken and reused in a later stratum as a building stone.

 

Written in Aramaic, the language of the Aramean kingdoms of Syria, it related the details of an invasion of Israel by an Aramean king whose name is not mentioned on the fragments that have so far been discovered. But there is hardly a question that it tells the story of the assault of Hazael, king of Damascus, on the northern kingdom of Israel around 835 BCE. … The most important part of the inscription is Hazael’s boasting description of his enemies: “[I killed Jeho]ram son of [Ahab] king of Israel, and [I] killed [Ahaz]jahu son of [Jehoram kin]g of the House of David. And I set [their towns into ruins and turned] their land into [desolation]”.

 

Elisha the patriot had lived to see the fulfilment of his prophecy that Hazael would set on fire Israel’s strongholds (2 Kings 8:12).

Yet, in the biblical narration, the annihilation of the royal house is attributed entirely to Jehu. This is yet another example of ‘biblical perspective’ and selectivity. But it is all one and the same thing, as Jehu was the subordinate of Hazael; the former doing the dirty work whilst the latter gave the orders and gained the credit for it. And this situation, we shall find, will prevail during the whole of their long partnership.

….

 

Now, continuing on into Chapter 5 of my thesis, and a consideration of Ay:

 

This chapter will largely be a continuation of my discussion of the Sinai-commissioned triumvirate of Hazael, Jehu and Elisha that I had begun in Chapter 4. But here the emphasis will be on Egypt, not Syro-Palestine. Once again our central character will be Jehu, but this time in his guise as an EA governor, subordinate to Hazael: both of whom would actually come to rule Egypt for a period of time. Some significant historical characters will emerge from these pages.

….

We might recall from Chapter 4 that the task assigned to Hazael, Jehu and Elisha had been to annihilate the House of Ahab and to destroy the cult of Baal in Syro-Palestine.

 

Thus so read the relevant Scriptures.

However, I believe that the commission actually extended further, to include Egypt (of no particular interest in this case to the biblical scribes) ….

….

 

Ay was … master of the horses [chariotry]’. Doherty, who has variously described Ay as “the king-maker, the overlord” and “cunning as a mongoose”,[4] also recounts Ay’s political machinations:[5]

 

Ay was … well placed for a position of great power. He never took the title of vizier [sic], that was too lowly an honour for the likes of him. Indeed, as I shall prove, Ay saw himself as wielding supreme power over Egypt and Pharaoh Tutankhamun, the fruit of years of scheming and plotting.

… A member of the powerful Akhmim clan, he would owe his rise not only to family connections but to his own innate ability and skill. Ay also proved to be a man who could swim with the tide and trim his sails to whatever wind blew.

 

Doherty also tells that Ay was, for a time, “for his own secret purposes” one of the Aton cult’s “most fervent supporters”.[6] He then describes Ay’s ‘Bismarckian’ influence:[7]

 

Ay was the head of the Akhmim Mafia. In this case the word Mafia most accurately describes his spider-like power and influence. Ay’s parents were the father and mother-in-law of the great Amenhotep III, his sister that magnificent Pharaoh’s Chief Wife and Great Queen ….

Ay could boast of powerful connections in the priestly caste of Amun through his brother Anen and be on speaking terms with all the great and good in Pharaoh’s court, as well as the civil and military administration.

….

Ay is portrayed as a sly old man. The evidence however indicates a Mafia chief of personal charisma, power and cunning, a man to be feared, a tough former soldier, a skilled administrator, held in awe for his talents by all at Pharaoh’s court. Ay was not some sly Polonius hiding behind the arras but rather the Metternich or Bismarck of post-Amarna Egypt.

 

Ay had in fact inherited the same range of devious political skills as had been possessed by the ‘duplicitous’ father of his whom he had murdered. He could emulate the latter’s (as Abdi-ashirta) wretched grovelling … (e.g. EA 64). Or - again like Kadashman-Enlil, who had urged Amenhotep III (EA 4) to change age-old Egyptian practice for his sake, by letting him marry the pharaoh’s daughter: “You are the king and you may do as you please. If you were to give a daughter, who would say anything about it?” - Ay might radically break with Egyptian tradition by his outrageous usurping of the place of the god Amun-Re, or Montu, in one of Tutankhamun’s smiting scenes.[8] “Here was a man with truly grandiose dreams”, wrote Brier.[9]

….

 

The Queen, Slain By Order of Jehu (Horemheb)

 

There are such striking similarities between the agent of the bloody purge in Israel, Jehu (serving Hazael), and the agent of the reform in Egypt, Horemheb (serving Ay), that I must identify ‘these’ as the one, same general. There is a description of Horemheb in his tomb - relating to before he came to the throne - that I think might well apply to Jehu, especially after the latter’s bloody massacre of Ahab’s line:[10] “… [a henchman] at the feet of his lord on the battle-field on this day of slaughtering Asiatics”.

 

Again, fully compatible with the biblical portraits of Jehu are Tyldesley’s references to Horemheb as “a solid, old-fashioned [pharaoh]”, possessing “excessive religious zeal”;[11] and Doherty’s descriptions of Horemheb as being “an inveterate red-neck [hating] everything [the cult of Aten] stood for [and] only too ready to launch the most savage persecution against [the cult]”.[12] As a balance to this, Collier has discussed Horemheb “as a good king” and a reformer of abuse.[13]

….

[Joyce] Tyldesley at least contrasts “the heretic [Atonist] regime [with] the orthodox Horemheb”.[14] But Horemheb, like Ay, as an EA official for Egypt, must have paid lip service to Atonism,[15] just as he as the converted Naaman still paid lip service to Rimmon in Damascus. Horemheb would have been largely absent anyway, defending Egypt’s borders.

….

 

…. The word ‘obscure’ is often used in regard to Horemheb and his origins. And this uncertainty about the great man is reflected in the following words by Velikovsky:[16]

 

It is regularly admitted that it is not known how and when Haremhab [Horemheb] became king of Egypt. Some think that he was the last king of the Eighteenth Dynasty; some place him at the beginning of the Nineteenth Dynasty. … He was not the son of a king, nor was he the father of Ramses I, who followed [sic] him. … “Nothing is known of his antecedents”.

 

My identification of Horemheb with Jehu should serve to lift the veil of obscurity surrounding the former. We know that Horemheb’s long and illustrious career had commenced during the reign of Amenhotep III, and had continued on through Akhnaton, reaching a high point during the reign of Tutankhamun. After that, things are somewhat less clear; but he is supposed to have succeeded Tutankhamun’s successor, Ay, himself having become pharaoh of Egypt for perhaps almost three decades (c. 1323 BC - 1295 BC, conventional dates). That is an exceedingly long floruit.

….

 

Queen Jezebel, having seen to the murder of so many in Israel (and perhaps also in Egypt),[17] would now meet her own bloody death, before the rampaging Jehu (Horemheb) (2 Kings 9:30-37):

 

When Jehu came to Jezreel, Jezebel heard of it; she painted her eyes with kohl, and adorned her head, and looked out of the Window. As Jehu entered the gate, she said, ‘Is it peace, Zimri, murderer of your master?’ He looked up to the Window and said, ‘Who is on my side? Who?’ Two or three eunuchs looked out at him. He said, ‘Throw her down’.

 

So they threw her down; some of her blood spattered on the wall and on the horses, which trampled on her. Then he went in and ate and drank; he said, ‘See to that cursed woman and bury her; for she is a king’s daughter’. But when they went to bury her, they found no more of her than the skull and the feet and the palms of her hands. When they came back and told him, he said, ‘This is the word of the Lord, which he spoke by his servant Elijah the Tishbite. ‘In the territory of Jezreel the dogs shall eat the flesh of Jezebel; the corpse of Jezebel shall be like dung on the field in the territory of Jezreel, so that no one can say. This is Jezebel’.’

….

 

This is a graphic narrative. Indeed, according to Ellis:[18]

 

The account of Jehu’s revolt has long been recognized as a masterpiece of historical narrative. The wealth of detail, the sure touch in the delineation of the various strong personalities involved, and the headlong pace of the narrative make it certain that the author is a contemporary and perhaps even an eyewitness.

 

….

Nor had [Queen Jezebel] been under any illusions about Jehu’s intentions for her. Far from having adorned herself for the purpose of attempting to seduce Jehu, she did so in order that she might face death like a queen. It was perfectly in keeping with Jezebel’s proud character. She even, by naming Jehu as ‘Zimri’ - no doubt intending this as an insult - recalled to Jehu’s mind that his grandfather (as I have interpreted it) had likewise staged a coup against the crown, thereby assuming rulership of Israel for himself.

….

Projecting back those 12 or so years from c. 841 BC, the approximate (conventional) year of the commencement of Jehu’s reign over Israel, when the queen met her violent death, we arrive right at the time of Ahab’s year of death in 853 BC (conventional date). This is a very encouraging chronological fit indeed. The queen noticeably disappears from the biblical narrative for this entire period.

….

 

Jehu/Horemheb: Ruler of Israel and Egypt

 

Jehu … was essentially a king of Israel where he ruled for 28 years, and was subsequently buried in Samaria with his ancestors (2 Kings 10:35-36), who I believe to have been Zimrides. …. Such I believe to have been the background to the enigmatic Horemheb, whose ‘parentage’ is thought to be ‘completely unknown.’ Doherty, for instance, considers Horemheb to have been “a northerner of obscure origins”.[19] He was certainly, I believe, “a northerner”; though his origins, as a Zimride, were far from being “obscure”. 

 

This Horemheb, as I am going to argue, matches Jehu in some significant ways. (For a quick summary, see points of comparison (a)-(g) on p. 245).

….

 

Basically, then, our main character was a governor for Egypt of Syro-Palestine, who - ever subordinate to Hazael (Ay) - eventually became the latter’s governor (vice regent), with more direct power over Egypt. In this guise, he was, I am arguing, Horemheb. “The nature of his duties must have removed Horemheb often from court”, wrote Collier.[20] And, according to Newby, “[Horemheb] had been an indefatigable traveller …”.[21]

 

Whilst Horemheb is accredited with 28 years of rule in Egypt, from c. 1323-1295 BC (conventional dates)[22] - exactly the same period of rule, incidentally, as Jehu had enjoyed - the archaeological evidence would not seem to support the view that Horemheb had ruled Egypt continuously for so substantial a period of time.

 

[Geoffrey] Gammon[23] may therefore have a point with his estimated “7/8 years” for the reign length of Horemheb inasmuch as - whilst Horemheb’s total length of kingship, as Jehu, may have been 28 years - perhaps only “7/8” of these involved his direct and individual rule of Egypt. A figure of around 8 years would probably account for the fact that Horemheb’s building activity in Egypt is considered not to represent nearly three decades of rule, consistent with my view that Horemheb was largely a ruler of Syro-Palestine, not Egypt. Gammon continues:[24] “... apart from instances of usurpation, Horemheb’s building activity was substantially less than that of Seti I in a period of between 10 and 15 years. Specifically, his tomb in the Valley of the Kings was unfinished at his death”.

 

Horemheb’s birth name and epithet are thought to have been Horemheb meryamun, meaning “Horus is in Jubilation, Beloved of Amun”; though there is some difference of opinion as to how the first part of this name is meant to be represented (e.g. Horemheb, Horemhab, Haremhab?).

The name Horemheb/Horam-heb, though it can certainly be a genuine Egyptian name, looks suspiciously also like the Hebrew name, Jehoram.

 

We have found that Jehoram was also a name used amongst the Omride royals. It is possible that Jehu too was variously called Jehoram; though the name by which he is known in the Bible, as king of Israel, is Jehu,[25] arising from ‘Yawheh’ and ‘huw’, and meaning ‘Yahweh (is) He’.

….

Jehu/Horemheb, as I have noted, cannot really be separated from Hazael/Ay, either in Egyptian or biblical history. Doherty has given a realistic account of these two characters (in their Egyptian guise), alike at least in their innate practicality, “born pragmatists”.[26] Horemheb though was perhaps the more refined, possessing, as he did, “a strong but sensitive face”.[27] Brier has, by contrast, gives an unflattering view of Ay’s appearance.[28]

 

The situation of Jehu as an apparent subordinate to Hazael seems to be paralleled in the case of their alter egos in Egyptian history. Consider, for example, Doherty’s estimation here:[29] “The Restoration Stela [Tutankhamun’s] committed Egypt to re-establishing its power abroad and this was Horemheb’s duty. Yet, even here there is evidence that, if Horemheb did the hard work, Ay … [was] more than prepared to take the glory”.

 

Horemheb was, as Jehu is represented in the Bible, the restorer of established order. This is indicated, as we saw, by his royal titulature (especially the verb seped, ‘setting things in order’). Horemheb is most famous as a reformer king; his Great Edict, or code of laws, was cruel but effective. He and Ay, and apparently Elisha as well, were law enforcers, or police, who depended on the sword to bring about order. We recall that Ay would adopt the cognomen: ‘Who is doing right’, and this motto seems to tie in well with Horemheb’s titulary seped and the Hebrew shaphat … ‘to judge, govern, administer right’.

 

….

Horemheb had … astonishing titles … [e.g. ‘King’s Deputy in All Countries’, ‘King’s Elect’, ‘The Greatest Amongst the Favourites of the Lord of the Two Countries’, ‘The True Scribe Well Beloved of the King’].[30] [Dr. Donovan] Courville marvelled at the nature of Horemheb’s titles and privileges.[31] That Horemheb was already at least quasi-pharaoh during the reign of Tutankhamun is quite apparent from the fact that Horemheb’s cartouche has been found together with that of Tutankhamun on commemorative stone slabs found at the base of sphinxes as part of the Avenue of Sphinxes at Karnak.[32]

 

During the reign of the feeble Tutankhamun, Ay (Hazael) and his colleague, Horemheb (Jehu), seem largely to have shared the royal power. Horemheb had married Mutnodjmet, thought by some to have been the sister of Nefertiti. Thus Doherty:[33] “Mutnedjmet apparently disappeared from Akhenaten’s court around Year 8 of that Pharaoh’s reign, I consider this to be the year she married Horemheb, a political marriage alliance arranged by Ay”. “Mutnodjmet”, writes Tyldesley,[34] “died aged between thirty-five and forty during Year 14 or 15 of her husband’s rule, and was buried in the tomb which Horemheb had prepared for himself at Memphis”. This was, she says, a “second marriage, following the death of his first wife …”.[35] Interestingly, both Ay and Horemheb would designate themselves as heir. …. In the case of Ay, for instance, Tyldesley has written:[36] “… Ay is described as the ‘Eldest King’s Son’, an obviously honorary title which nevertheless implies that the elderly Ay is recognized as the young Tutankhamen’s heir”.  

 

And Doherty has written similarly about Horemheb, in regard to his statue in the Turin Museum:[37] “The impression given by these inscriptions is that Horemheb not only became Pharaoh but that he was his predecessor’s legitimate heir”. Who his “predecessor” actually was, however, “is left vague”.[38]

 

During the reign of Tutankhamun, Horemheb became King’s Deputy (and very likely vice-regent), then quasi-pharaoh, with Ay (Hazael). “The coronation proclamation depicts Horemheb sweeping into Thebes to a rapturous reception”, writes Doherty.[39]

Did he ‘sweep in’ on his chariot, just as he (as general Jehu) had swept through the Valley of Jezreel to despatch king Jehoram, and the latter’s mother, Jezebel (2 Kings 9)?

 

Jehu … matches Horemheb … in at least the following significant ways, as:

 

(a) an army commander, charioteer, apparently allied to a Syrian (Assyrian) potentate; as

(b) likely a non-Egyptian;

(c) chronologically, in a revised context;

(d) having reigned for 28 years;

(e) a cruel law enforcer;

(f) restorer of the status quo;

(g) a fanatical religious reformer-king.

 

We know nothing from Egyptian records about the death of Horemheb. His mummy has not been found. The reason for this, I suggest, is because he was not buried in Egypt (cf. 2 Kings 10:35). Now, my revised date for the death of Horemheb, in identifying him with Jehu, would be c. 815/814 BC ….

 

According to Booth:[40] “Considering that Horemheb was one of the most important kings of the eighteenth dynasty [sic], who instigated major changes and reforms in what was essentially a country of chaos after the Amarna Period, there is very little evidence of his life and times. There is more evidence of the 17-year reign of Akhenaten than the 27-year reign of Horemheb”.

….



[1] The Wonders of Bible Chronology, p. 53.

[2] N. Grimal, A History of Ancient Egypt, p. 243.

[3] The Bible Unearthed, p. 129. Tiglath-pileser III may later have distinguished a kingdom of ‘Beth-Hazael’ separately from ‘Beth-Omri’. See S. Irvine, Isaiah, Ahaz, and the Syro-Ephraimitic Crisis’, cf. pp. 40, 60.

[4] The Mysterious Death of Tutankhamun, pp. 149, 81.

[5] Ibid, pp. 77, 78, 79.

[6] Velikovsky had, in this same context, mentioned that “certain historians” have actually credited Ay with the authorship of “the self-glorifying Akhnaton’s hymn”. Op. cit. p. 116.

[7] Op. cit, p. 79.

[8] Ibid, p. 147.

[9] The Murder of Tutankhamen, p. 108.

[10] A. Gardiner, ‘The Memphite Tomb of the General Haremhab’, pp. 3-4. Cf. K. Pflüger, Haremhab und die Amarnazeit, p. 16; also R. Hari, Horemheb et la reine Moutnodjemet, p. 89, and Plate XIV. J. Collier has argued that Horemheb’s king (“lord”) at this time was Akhnaton. Op. cit, pp. 177-178.

[11] Op. cit, p. 185.

[12] Op, cit, pp. 79-80.

[13] Op. cit, p. 223.

[14] Op. cit, p. 60.

[15] See Doherty, op. cit, p. 75.

[16] The Assyrian Conquest, part II: “The Assyrians in Egypt”.

[17] See ibid, pp. 185-187, for a description of the religious persecution by the Atonist régime.

[18] ‘1-2 Kings’, 10:56, p. 200.

[19] Op. cit, p. 41.

[20] Op. cit, p. 151.

[21] Warrior Pharaohs, p. 136.

[22] Grimal’s dates for Horemheb. Op. cit, p. 392.

[23] ‘The Place of Horemheb in Egyptian History’, p. 85. Gammon’s estimation concurs with an earlier one of 8 years made by J. Harris, ‘How Long was the Reign of Haremheb?’, pp. 95ff.

[24] Ibid.

[25] Liel considers this name to be the same as EA’s Iawa/Iama, op. cit, section: “Iawa”.

[26] Op. cit, p. 96.

[27] Ibid, p. 80.

[28] Op. cit, p. 187.

[29] Op. cit, p. 117. Emphasis added.

[30] Ibid, p. 124.

[31] Op. cit, p. 288.

[32] J. Zwick, ‘The Age of Pharaoh Haremhab’, with reference to KMT Magazine, Vol. 10, Summer, 1999, p. 38.

[33] Op. cit, p. 81.

[34] Op. cit, pp. 184-185.

[35] Ibid, p. 184.

[36] Ibid, p. 182.

[37] Op. cit, p. 217.

[38] Ibid, p. 226.

[39] Ibid.

[40] People of Ancient Egypt, p. 164.

Friday, March 27, 2026

Comparing titles: Aye and Amenhotep Hapu

 


 

by

 

Damien F. Mackey

 

 

 

Conventionally, about three decades separate the death of the revered scribe

and sage, Amenhotep son of Hapu (d. 1356 BC) from the beginning of the reign

of Aye, or Ay (c. 1326 BC). Despite that, the impressive titles borne are similar.

 

 

Hopefully, I have been able to lift away the heavy veil that enshrouds the famous, but most enigmatic, Amenhotep son of Hapu, chief official of the Eighteenth Dynasty pharaoh Amenhotep ‘the Magnificent’, by identifying him with the similarly enigmatic and supposedly ‘obscure’ prince Amenhotep who became pharaoh Akhnaton:

 

Akhnaton not obscure before he became Pharaoh

 

(18) Akhnaton not obscure before he became Pharaoh

 

Now, given the likenesses of the extraordinary titles borne by Amenhotep son of Hapu and those borne by Aye, who seems to emerge to prominence from out of nowhere, I today (27th March, 2026) have begun to wonder if there might be a most significant extra dimension to the composite Amenhotep-Akhnaton in the form of Aye.

 

Titles

 

Amenhotep, Vizier and Chief Architect, accrued an ever-expanding array of titles throughout the extensive and prosperous reign of Amenhotep III, ultimately solidifying his status as the quintessential statesman:

 

Military Titles, including: Chief of the Memphis Army, Chief of Recruitment, Governor and Scribe of the Soldiers…

 

Religious Titles, such as: Priest Shem, First Prophet of Athribis, Great Celebrant of Amun, Intendant of the flocks of Amun…

 

Civil Titles, comprising: Royal Scribe, Head of the Census, Head of Public Works, and most notably, Head of all the King’s work, which elevated him to the position of royal architect—a title he seemed to hold with great pride.

 

Courtly Titles, denoting his close relationship with the monarchy, such as: Friend of the King, Bearer of the Royal Seal, Fan-bearer on the Right Side of the King, Administrator of the estate of Sitamun, daughter of Amenhotep III.

 

Count, Sole Companion, Fanbearer on the King's Right Hand, Chief of the King's Works, Royal Scribe, Scribe of the Recruits, Overseer of the Cattle of Amun in the South and North, High Priest of Horus at Athribis, God's Father, and Steward of Princess-Queen Sitamun.[1]

 

Aye was:

 

  • Overseer of all the horses of his majesty
  • Troop Commander
  • Overseer of horses
  • Fan-bearer on the right side of the king
  • Acting scribe of the king
  • Grand Vizier
  • Father of the god
  • Shem priest.

 

Amenhotep, Aye, in common: Grand Vizier; Army Commander; Fan-bearer on the right side of the king; Scribe; Father of the god; shem priest, etc.

 

 

Monday, December 8, 2025

Reflecting on the biblical Egyptology of Ron Wyatt’s wife, Mary Nell (Lee)

by Damien F. Mackey According to Mary Nell, Ron believed that he had been able to work out the complexities of Egyptian dynastic history in relation to the Bible only because God had enabled him to do so. Otherwise, it would have been impossible considering the intricacies of the subject. Yesterday, the eve of today’s feast-day of the Immaculate Conception (8th December, 2025), I came across a video by Mary Nell (Lee) Wyatt on the high official, Senenmut, of Egypt’s Eighteenth Dynasty: NEW Discovery | Ron Wyatt Found Evidence For Moses In Egypt! Prior to this, Mary Nell Wyatt was for me just a name that I had seen associated with, as his wife, the well-known Ron Wyatt. Thus I was stunned to hear her expatiate at great length and fluency on Egyptology, from the First Dynasty all the way through to the Eighteenth, in relation to her large book: Battle for the Firstborn: The Exodus and the Death of Tutankhamen (2020). Mary Nell’s narrative, heavily based upon the research of her deceased husband, gives as plausible account as most have been able to do of biblical history, from Abram (Abraham) to Moses, in its relation to the Egyptian dynasties. And it is highly original. Apparently, before the pair (met or) married, Ron had lived in Hawaii and had there, in the library, voraciously devoured books on history. What enhances Mary Nell’s presentation is she herself, a very likeable person who can listen patiently to her interviewer’s questions – unlike some guest speakers who want to talk all the time, talk all over the interviewer, and, when they do pause to listen, ostensibly, seem tense and impatient to re-commence their diatribe. According to Mary Nell, Ron believed that he had been able to work out the complexities of Egyptian dynastic history in relation to the Bible only because God had enabled him to do so. Otherwise, it would have been impossible considering the intricacies of the subject. Now she, as Ron’s successor, believes that the model that she has laid out in her book is the correct one. + + + + + Today’s feast of the Immaculate Conception recalls the one human person (Jesus, though having a fully human nature, was a Divine Person) in history who was not deceived, over whom the Devil never had any dominance. It is one thing to say that we are instruments of the Holy Spirit, but are we really? Might we be deceiving ourselves – or allowing the Devil, the Father of Lies (John 8:44), to deceive us? I remember years ago being turned off Ron Wyatt when I read that he would come to some mound and go all rigid with the Holy Spirit, standing there and pointing at the mound, within which some great biblical discovery, presumably, was waiting to be revealed. His gullible followers would then hasten keenly to start digging there. But nothing ever seemed to come to fruition. At the fateful moment, for example, the Israeli authorities (or some other unforeseen situation) would intervene, preventing the team from continuing. Nothing was ever able to come to fruition. The fact of the matter was, there was no fruition! Apparently the state of Israel is quite prepared to let loose such Christian Zionist amateur archaeologist types to dig in areas of no significance, looking on benignly while the Christians hope to add to their ‘amazing’ discoveries of no significance: Christian Zionists a boon to Israel, but sadly mistaken about Final Coming and Third Temple (7) Christian Zionists a boon to Israel, but sadly mistaken about Final Coming and Third Temple Another key point that we need to consider in studies such as this is that there is a world of difference between knowledge and wisdom, which is an inspired gift of the Holy Spirit. Knowledge is, too, of course (cf. Isaiah 11:2), but here I am talking about knowledge in natural terms, as knowing a whole lot of stuff. Our academic world is full of purveyors of much stuff, but wisdom can often seem to be in very short supply: Trenchant Criticisms of the Academic World (5) Trenchant Criticisms of the Academic World There is nothing self-deceptive in the wise man – the wise woman, Mary Immaculate. Take the prophet Daniel, as an example. He knew by the power of the Holy Spirit that what he had interpreted in relation to King Nebuchednezzar’s Dream, a humanly impossible assignment, was absolutely correct, coming as it did from God (Daniel 2:45): “The dream is true and its interpretation is trustworthy”. This is what the Wyatt’s appear to have been claiming, as well. But can the same be said, “true”, “trustworthy” for their admittedly impressive (at least superficially) biblical Egyptology? The prophet Daniel’s wisdom was built upon prayer and fasting, and strict obedience. And there was no self-seeking, or ego, in it. Once the ego takes over, and a reputation is gained, one may feel pressure to ‘doctor’ digging sites, to start planting artefacts, as Ron Wyatt has often been accused of doing. All in the name of God, of course: Abandonment of common sense, telling lies for God, not necessary prerequisites for biblical interpretation (4) Abandonment of common sense, telling lies for God, not necessary prerequisites for biblical interpretation Professor Ian Plimer is not the problem here! The Wyatt version of Egyptology I like the fact that Ron Wyatt had approached Egyptology from the point of view of covering the extensive biblical phase from Abram (Abraham) to Moses, rather than simply focussing upon just one segment, e.g. the Famine era of Joseph. A holistic approach. How well, though, does he and his wife’s Egyptological platform serve for setting up later major events, archaeologically and/or geographically verifiable, such as Joshua’s Conquest of Jericho, and Shishak of Egypt’s despoliation of the Temple of Yahweh? If it be a case of a Danielic type of inspiration from the Holy Spirit, then the whole thing must, like Nebuchednezzar’s Dream, fall lock, stock and barrel, right into place. Sadly, as we are going to find out, this will not be the case. Once again, there will be a lack of fruition, unlike: An accurate revision of history is a ‘tree’ bearing ample fruit (7) An accurate revision of history is a 'tree' bearing ample fruit And if such be so, then it cannot justifiably be claimed to have been inspired by the Holy Spirit. Abraham and Joseph Mary Nell gets off to a very good start, so I believe, by supposing Abraham to have lived at the beginning of Egyptian dynastic history, First or Second Dynasty. It gets even better with her identification of Joseph with the great Imhotep, who served Horus Netjerikhet, a Famine Pharaoh, of Egypt’s Third Dynasty. Creationist Patrick Clarke, who will locate Joseph during Egypt’s Eleventh Dynasty, will refer critically to the Wyatt thesis here in his article: “Joseph’s Zaphenath Paaneah—a chronological key” (JOURNAL OF CREATION 27(3) 2013 || VIEWPOINT): …. Wyatt creates far greater problems by linking Joseph to the famous Imhotep. …. Wyatt (using the conventional Egyptian chronology as the guide) must move Imhotep and Zoser around seven centuries nearer the birth of Christ. …. Given the unsuitability of the choices of pharaohs and names for Joseph above, is there a suitable pharaonic candidate who meets the biblical requirements? Mentuhotep II appears to meet these requirements perfectly, needing a movement of three centuries rather that the stress-inducing seven centuries required by Wyatt above. …. The fact is (my opinion) that, to identify Joseph and Moses, one needs to knit together, as one, several Egyptian dynasties, even kingdoms. Both Wyatt and Clarke are correct that (Wyatt) Joseph is the Third Dynasty Imhotep and (Clarke) that he belonged to the Eleventh Dynasty Famine era of Mentuhotep II. See how I have connected all this, and more, in my article: Symmetrical dynastic links for Famine Pharaoh and Joseph (4) Symmetrical dynastic links for Famine Pharaoh and Joseph But both Wyatt and Clarke are wrong, however, in naming the Third Dynasty (Famine) Pharaoh as Zoser (see my article again). As far back as 1987, Tom Chetwynd had opined that Joseph may have been Imhotep (“A Seven Year Famine in the Reign of King Djoser with Other Parallels between Imhotep and Joseph”, Catastrophism and Ancient History, Volume IX, Part I). Did the Wyatt’s come to this conclusion independently? That can happen. Whatever be the case, it would be nice as a general courtesy if writers would indicate whenever they had adopted an idea from someone else. Whilst listening to Mary Nell most capably deliver her long account of Egyptian history, I wondered at times what happened to certain very important dynasties or rulers. For instance – and perhaps she has dealt with this in her book – the mighty Twelfth Dynasty of Egypt did not seem to get any reasonable mention at all. This, I believe, to have been the very dynasty (or one of them, as merging is necessary) that had begun the Oppression of Israel when Moses was born: Egypt’s Twelfth Dynasty oppressed Israel (6) Egypt's Twelfth Dynasty oppressed Israel Mary Nell scoots through a whole swathe of dynasties and ends up in the Seventeenth, with Pharaoh Kamose as her first Oppressor King of Israel (cf. Exodus 1:8). This is a startlingly long jump from Imhotep as Joseph, in Egypt’s Third Dynasty (c. 2600 BC, conventional dating) to the infancy of Moses presumably under Kamose (c. 1550 BC, conventional dating). Biblically estimated, Moses was born only about 65 years after the death of Joseph. And now for the intriguing identification of Moses as the high Eighteenth Dynasty official, Senenmut – a view that has become extremely popular in recent times – with Moses’s Egyptian foster-mother as Hatshepsut. Bizarrely, Mary Nell chooses to identify the male Senenmut in statues as a female: Quite missing from her treatment of the Eighteenth Dynasty (at least in the video) is another much favoured candidate for Moses, the monotheistic pharaoh, Akhnaton. I do not recall Mary Nell even mentioning him. After Akhnaton came the famous Tutankhamun, Pharaoh’s ill-fated first born (see title of Mary Nell’s book). Actually, Smenkhkare is considered to have been Tutankhamun’s older brother, and apparently his features, and not those of Tutankhamun, are what adorn the royal mask. (Mary Nell claims that these are Tut’s father’s features): Tut’s famous middle coffin probably belonged to his predecessor Smenkhkare (6) Tut's famous middle coffin probably belonged to his predecessor Smenkhkare Dr. I. Velikovsky’s intuitive (though not properly worked out) identifications of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III, of Egypt’s Eighteenth Dynasty, with, respectively, the biblical Queen of Sheba and King Shishak (Ages in Chaos, I, 1952), are far preferable, I would think, to Mary Nell’s admittedly intriguing and original scenario. And I was able in 1997 to include the addition of Senenmut, as (not Mary Nell’s Moses) King Solomon in Egypt (pairing with the Queen of Sheba, Hatshepsut): Solomon and Sheba (8) Solomon and Sheba All of this segues very nicely into Dr. Velikovsky’s thesis that pharaoh Thutmose III (Shishak), in his Year 22-23 (First Campaign) despoiled the Temple in Jerusalem, about 5 years after the death of King Solomon. The chronology is virtually exact, locking in, as it does, with Senenmut’s (as Solomon) fading from the Egyptian records around Year 16 (of Hatshepsut and Thutmose III). Dr. Velikovsky had made quite a mess, though, of putting together the geography of Thutmose III’s campaign unto Jerusalem, which I hope to have rectified in articles such as: Yehem near Aruna - Thutmose III’s march on Jerusalem (6) Yehem near Aruna - Thutmose III's march on Jerusalem I do not know if Mary Nell’s version of Egyptian history has projected this far ahead. But why I do know that the Egyptological reconstruction of the Wyatt’s is faulty, and thus not locked in as “trustworthy” by the Holy Spirit, is because any New Kingdom reconstruction of the Exodus will have as its consequence the sore fact that, when Joshua will arrive at Jericho, there will be no city there for him to attack. As I wrote in my article (favouring that holistic approach): From Raamses to the ‘Sea of Reeds’ (8) From Raamses to the 'Sea of Reeds' …. Why the new Kingdom is totally inappropriate While, superficially, a New Kingdom (Eighteenth or Nineteenth Dynasty) setting for the Exodus might appear to fit the bill, it would actually cause far more problems than it may seemingly manage to solve. For it is not sufficient simply to grab a particular phase out of history and claim that it attaches nicely to a biblical event. The Bible records a long, developing history which necessitates that the whole thing be fitted into an historical and archaeological framework. If, for instance, one were to take Ramses II as the Pharaoh of the Exodus, one would then need to be able to situate, each into its own proper place, Joseph and the Famine at an earlier phase of Egyptian history, and, then, Abram (Abraham), before Joseph. On this note, Dr. John Osgood has rightly, in a recent article (2024): https://assets.answersresearchjournal.org/doc/v17/ jericho_dating_joshuas_conquest_of_canaan_comments_osgood.pdf Answers Research Journal 17 (2024): 221–222, “The Walls of Jericho: Dating Joshua’s Conquest of Canaan—Comments”, expressed his ‘amazement’ when those involved in biblico-historical reconstructions exclude “a whole saga of history”: …. Habermehl tells us that “we note that the Bible does not say that Hiel built a city, but only a wall.” Really, then what do the words “Hiel of Bethel built Jericho” mean? It had a foundation (not specifically of a wall) and it had gates (1 Kings 16:34). But the archaeologists have clearly and categorically found a large city during Middle Bronze on the site of Jericho and therefore before Hiel. That city needs an explanation, as it won’t go away. This is where I am amazed at the blindness of both conventional and revisionist discussions, as if the pages of the book of Judges are stuck together and a whole saga of history is excluded. Namely, there was the attack on Jericho, the city of palm trees, by Eglon of Moab, and for 20 years that site was occupied by 10,000 of his troops (Judges 3:12– 30, see also Deuteronomy 34:3; Judges 1:16; 2 Chronicles 28:15—the city of palm trees). …. [End of quote] Nor will it be sufficient to focus only upon Egypt – though that nation was, admittedly, the main power during the biblical era from the patriarchs Abram (Abraham) to Moses. Mesopotamia, Syria, Canaan, and so on, must likewise be properly accounted for, both historically and archaeologically. Key to a biblico-historical synthesis will obviously be the Conquest of Canaan and its centrepiece, the Fall of Jericho, which outstanding episode should be archaeologically verifiable. Pharaoh Ramses II may indeed have had his wonderful horses and chariots, but, for those who hold him to have been the Pharaoh of the Exodus, these are now faced with a Late Bronze Age (LBA) archology for the Conquest, and for Jericho, that is hopelessly inadequate. Much has been written about this. Stuart Zachary Steinberg briefly sums it up here: Redating the Conquest of the Promised Land | by Stuart Zachary Steinberg | Medium “For nearly 150 years the conquest by the Israelites has been dated to the Late Bronze Age. The reason for that has been primarily placing the Exodus in the Late Kingdom to have Raamses II as the pharaoh of the Exodus, to correspond with Exodus where it states that the children of Israel built the store cities of Pithom and Raamses. The problem is that there are nearly no correspondence[s] between the destruction of various cities and archaeology in the Late Bronze Age (LBA). Most [of] the cities mentioned do not exist or were destroyed much earlier. Case in point is Jericho. During the Late Bronze Age there was no city at Jericho for Joshua to destroy”. This is the dire situation that confronts the conventional scholars and whoever else might look to situate the Exodus at the time of Egypt’s New Kingdom. The high point of the Conquest of Canaan by Joshua was the destruction of Jericho, whose walls famously fell down. However: “During the Late Bronze Age there was no city at Jericho for Joshua to destroy”. Boom, boom. This is that lack of fruition, again – no lock, stock and barrel co-ordination.

Thursday, November 13, 2025

Bloody Ugaritic cycle of Baal-Anat draws upon famed biblical warriors

by Damien F. Mackey “Just as Anat purges both "field" and "house," so Jehu purges both "field" and "house." Just as Anat adorns herself and puts on paint, so Jezebel adorns her self and puts on paint”. Michael S. Moore As Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky was able to demonstrate, the spectacular corpus of Ugarit (modern Ras Shamra) has been dated far too early by the historians of antiquity. On this, see my article: Ugarit (Ras Shamra), Hebrew, the Greeks (3) Ugarit (Ras Shamra), Hebrew, the Greeks The typical view dates them early. Thus: Ugaritic texts - Wikipedia The Ugaritic texts are a corpus of ancient cuneiform texts discovered in 1928 in Ugarit (Ras Shamra) and Ras Ibn Hani in Syria, and written in Ugaritic, an otherwise unknown Northwest Semitic language. Approximately 1,500 texts and fragments have been found to date. The texts were written in the 13th and 12th centuries BCE. The most famous of the Ugarit texts are the approximately fifty epic poems; the three major literary texts are the Baal Cycle, the Legend of Keret, and the Tale of Aqhat. The other texts include 150 tablets describing the Ugaritic cult and rituals, 100 letters of correspondence, a very small number of legal texts (Akkadian is considered to have been the contemporary language of law), and hundreds of administrative or economic texts. …. Naturally, the commentaries on these texts tend to follow the conventional dating. Thus Michael S. Moore, taking the textbook view, will have the Ugaritic mythology influencing the supposedly later biblical texts. While this is the usual knee-jerk default, the reality is the other way around. JEHU'S CORONATION AND PURGE OF ISRAEL by MICHAEL S. MOORE Fuller Theological Seminary, U.S.A. Michael S. Moore commences: Article-Jehus-Purge.pdf …. This paper will attempt a new reading of the Jehu tradition by reading it alongside the Baal-Anat cycle from Ugarit (KTU 1.3 i-iii). To anticipate my conclusions, I will argue that Jehu's coronation and purge is most likely a multi-leveled parody of a well-known religious tradition, and further, that its primary goal is to narrate an important episode in Israel's history in a way that appropriately ridicules the religious traditions of Israel's enemies. …. Parodying the "purge" What follows next is literarily fascinating. As is well-known, ever since KTU 1.3 came to light in 1930,43 scholars have puzzled over Anat's behavior.44 To explain it, some have tried to tie her myth to a seasonal calendar, supposing Anat's "bloodbath" to be a primitive attempt to revive the land's "vegetative spirit."45 Some have hypothesized that Anat's devotees may have engaged in some sort of homeopathic ritual for which the myth is a blueprint—perhaps a "ritual combat" designed to provoke Baal into ending the sterility of summer and sending down the autumn rains.46 Whatever the anthropological possibilities, others have noticed a number of intertextual parallels between this myth and various sections of the Hebrew Bible.47 Ph. Stern, for example, takes M. Smith's48 suggestions about Anat generally and applies them to Psa. xxiii, pointing out a number of common references to "tables among enemies," the destruction of both "house and valley," and the "house of the deity."49 Before his death, P. Craigie proposed that the Song of Deborah parallels the Anat myth in at least five ways: (1) Deborah, like Anat, has a male warrior assistant; (2) Deborah, like Anat, is a leader of warriors; (3) Deborah "dominates" (tdrkp) on the battlefield, just as Anat is a mistress of "dominion" (drkt); (4) Anat is a "maiden" (rhm), so too Deborah is a "maiden" (rhm); and (5) Deborah, like Anat, commands a military host of stars.50 Craigie believed that Dtr was quite aware of this tradition, whether or not it ever found a home in a specific cult dedicated solely to Anat.51 With regard to the myth's structure, however, J. Lloyd has helpfully suggested that Anat engages in two separate battles because at the root of this myth lies the primordial desire of conquerors to perfect their military conquests with corresponding religious sacrifices. Citing epi graphic and iconographie evidence from Moab, Egypt, and Ugarit, Lloyd suggestively proposes that conquerors cannot declare total vic tory until prisoners-of-war are brought before the (statue of the) appropriate deity, and put to death. "It is only once the actions of war are carried out within the microcosm of the temple itself that perfection is achieved."52 Assuming Lloyd is correct, I am inclined to think that the narrator of II Kings ix-x might be deliberately parodying the Anat tradition in order to propel his anti-Baalist program to a higher intensity-level. Just as Anat purges the earth, so Jehu purges Israel. Just as Anat purges both "field" and "house," so Jehu purges both "field" and "house." Just as Anat adorns herself and puts on paint, so Jezebel adorns her self and puts on paint. The following chart breaks down all the parallels I can find into subcategories of characterization, plot, and theme.53 Jehu's purge (II Kings ix 14-x 36) Anat's purge (KTU 1.3 i-iii) Characterization • One purging tool: Jehu One purging tool: Anat • Two enemies (Joram & Ahaziah) Two "enemies" (Gapnu & Ugar) • Jehu stacks 70 "heads" (rō'šîm) Anat kicks "heads" (riš) around like "balls" • Jehu "fills his hand" with the Anat's signature weapon is her "bow" bow (qešet) (qšt) 54 • Jezebel adorns herself Anat adorns herself • Jezebel uses pûk on her eyes Anat uses ánhb on her eyes ("snail ("antinomy") dye") • Jezebel looks out a window Anat closes "the gates" • Jezebel's "palms" (kap) Anat proudly wears the "palms" (kp) are barely visible of warriors on her belt • Jezebel's "skull," "feet" and "hands" Anat's "liver," "heart," "knees" and are her only remains "fingers" participate in her victory Plot • Two battles: one in the field, Two battles: one in the field, one in the one in Baal's "house" (bêt) "palace" (bht) of Anat • Jehu "meets" (qārâ) several Anat "meets" (qry) "pages" (ģlm) officials before final battle before final battle • Jehu meets Joram at Naboth's Anat meets enemies at the "foot "field" of the rock" (bšt ģr) • Jehu shoots an arrow (hēsî) Anat shoots "old men" (šbm) through sickly Joram's heart with her "shafts" (mt) • House of Baal has a "city" Anat fights "between two cities" in it (îr) (bn qrytm) • Jezebel mocks her enemies Anat mocks her enemies • Jezebel's "blood" (dâm) spatters Anat plunges her knees into "blood" (dm) Theme • Justice Purgation • Prophetic covenant Priestly power • "House" "House" • Reward for obedience Celebration of enemies' defeat Characterization Keeping in mind Jemielity's cautions about satire's "generic instability" and "controlled chaos",56 I want to emphasize at the outset of these comparisons that no literary comparison can ever be "certain,"57 especially when informed scholars cannot agree on matters as basic as tablet placement and/or narrative sequence. Some of these parallels will seem more convincing than others. Still, the main characters in these two traditions enact "flat" roles as purifying agents.™ Anat purges both valley and town on behalf of Baal, her master and lord. Jehu likewise purges Israel on behalf of Yahweh, his master and lord. In the Canaanite myth, Anat "raises her voice" against two low-level deities, Gapnu and Ugar, and vigorously defends her brother Baal from further divine attack.59 In the Hebrew story, Jehu does not even bother to converse with, he simply exterminates the kings of Israel and Judah (Joram and Ahaziah), and by so doing the narrator immediately deflates these kings' exaggerated self-image, paralleling them, how ever subtly, with Canaanite demi-gods at "the lowest level of the divine assembly."60 Moreover, each agent focuses on the "perfection" (Lloyd's term) of their respective purges; i.e., each purges something "outside" (field/wilder ness) as well as something "inside" (city/temple). In the Canaanite text, Anat does this by kicking her enemies' heads around like soccer balls and wearing their palms into battle like war-trophies.61 In the Hebrew text, Jehu stacks up his enemies' heads before Samaria's gate, then forces his foes to look at them while he makes a speech.62 Further, since myths are intentionally designed to be fluid and repetitious, several of these parallels easily shift back and forth between similarly "flat" characters, whether the parallel is between Anat-Jehu or Anat-Jezebel.63 Just as Anat mocks her enemies, so Jezebel mocks hers, calling Jehu "Zimri" (the infamous assassin-king who precedes the Omrides).64 And while we might speculate why Anat adorns herself,65 Jezebel's motives seem a bit more obvious. Jezebel paints her eyes because Anat paints her eyes. Jezebel puts on antimony (pûk) because Anat puts on murex (ánhb). Whether this is warpaint or mascara is never stated in either text, but Dtr seizes on it to heighten his satire and intensify his parody. Apparently he wants to satirize this Phoenician queen on several levels, even down to the details of her personal toilette.66 This parody continues on into the narrative about her death. In the myth, Anat's liver "swells with laughter" as she "washes her hands in the blood of the guards, her fingers in the gore of the warriors."67 In Dtr, however, Jezebel's "skull" no longer laughs, nor do her "hands" write false letters, nor do her "feet" any longer walk on family land stolen away from murdered Israelites. Just as Anat sheds her enemies' blood, so Jehu sheds his enemies' blood. Readers even nominally familiar with the Baal-Anat cycle would have no problem grasping these parallels. ….

Monday, October 13, 2025

Hiel of Bethel and the rebuilding of Jericho

by Damien F. Mackey “I built Qeriho” [or “Qericho” - Jericho] with prisoners from Israel”. King Mesha of Moab In e.g. my article: Unwrapping “Hiel of Bethel” (5) Unwrapping "Hiel of Bethel" the mysterious biblical character, Hiel (I Kings 16:34), was identified with King Mesha of Moab. Some of the reasons for this were: The Stele of Mesha affords the first clue towards our ascertaining who was the mysterious “Hiel of Bethel”, who rebuilt Jericho in the days of Ahab. For Mesha, a known (from the Moabite Stele) contemporary of Ahab and his sons – as was Hiel – records for us that he built Jericho (“I built Qeriho”, or “Qericho”), as he called it, “with prisoners from Israel”. This means that Mesha, a long time rival of Israel, must also have had some strong connection with (preferably control over) Israel’s city of Bethel. Until the days of Ahab’s son, Jehoram, Mesha was paying a large tribute to Israel (2 Kings 3:4). But he then revolted (3:1-27). Mesha further fits as Hiel insofar as Mesha, too, was known to have sacrificed his own sons (3:27), as Joshua had foretold that the (then un-named) restorer of Jericho would do (Joshua 6:26). For an accurate archaeology of the Old Testament, specifically from Abram (Abraham) through to the Judges, Dr. John Osgood has been something of a guru for me. He has absolutely pinned down the Genesis 14 rampage of the four kings at the time of Abram to the Late Chalcolithic period, while others were floundering around in the Middle Bronze I (MBI) period for Abram (Abraham), which is actually the archaeology for the Exodus Israelites. And Dr. Osgood has nailed this, too. No reasonable person ought now doubt that the MBI nomads were (not Abraham’s mob, but) the Israelites led by Moses and Joshua. And here, again, he authoritatively settles the matter of Hiel’s Jericho: https://assets.answersresearchjournal.org/doc/v17/jericho_dating_joshuas_conquest_of_canaan_comments_osgood.pdf Answers Research Journal 17 (2024): 221–222. The Walls of Jericho: Dating Joshua’s Conquest of Canaan—Comments J. M. Osgood, Independent Research, Bunjurgen, Queensland, Australia. Abstract Habermehl’s (2024) discussion of Jericho has presented a good case for the Conquest, but then Habermehl loses her way archaeologically regarding the building of Jericho under Hiel the Bethelite. …. In her recent paper, Habermehl (2024) has argued a good case for the archaeological horizon of the Conquest, and a number of revisionists including myself are in agreement with that identification. It is the only logical place where a significant change of culture occurs consistent with biblical predictions (Osgood 2020). However, Habermehl (2024) then claims the rebuilding of Jericho during Middle Bronze 1 by Hiel (1 Kings 16:34). This latter conclusion is illogical even against her own previous claims, as I will show. Now Habermehl (2018) has gone on record as claiming that the Eighteenth Dynasty of Egypt sits against the early Kingdom of Israel. I will not enter into the specifics of her conclusions here, but I have a difference of opinion on her claim, and I accept that general correlation. However, if that conclusion is held, and we know that the Eighteenth Dynasty is clearly associated with the Late Bronze age, then Hiel’s building was after the early part of Israel’s kingdom, during the time of Ahab. This, clearly by her own claims here, Hiel could not have rebuilt Jericho before or even during the Middle Bronze age. In fact, the likely horizon of that rebuilt Jericho would be around the Late Bronze/Iron 1 interface. Habermehl (2024) seems to place an arbitrary 500 years on the MB 1 (also known as EB/MB), a period I have argued suggests the nomadic then settling Israelites (Osgood 2020a, b), and so would not cover more than ca. 100 years. But I won’t labor that point. Habermehl tells us that “we note that the Bible does not say that Hiel built a city, but only a wall.” Really, then what do the words “Hiel of Bethel built Jericho” mean? It had a foundation (not specifically of a wall) and it had gates (1 Kings 16:34). But the archaeologists have clearly and categorically found a large city during Middle Bronze on the site of Jericho and therefore before Hiel. That city needs an explanation, as it won’t go away. This is where I am amazed at the blindness of both conventional and revisionist discussions, as if the pages of the book of Judges are stuck together and a whole saga of history is excluded. Namely, there was the attack on Jericho, the city of palm trees, by Eglon of Moab, and for 20 years that site was occupied by 10,000 of his troops (Judges 3:12–30, see also Deuteronomy 34:3; Judges 1:16; 2 Chronicles 28:15—the city of palm trees). Now a problem of understanding exists here, for if Eglon built on Jericho, why did he not fit into the curse uttered by Joshua? Examination of that curse and the story of Hiel will explain it. Although it was a curse, it cannot be claimed that it was a curse for anyone who rebuilt it, but was in fact a specific prophecy as well, under the inspirational guidance of the Holy Spirit. Hiel had taken on Baal worship, and a part of Baal worship was the deliberate sacrifice of children. Hiel killed his firstborn son Abiram, placed his small body in a ceramic jar as the Baal worshipers were wont to do, and buried it in the foundation of Jericho. In so doing he dedicated Jericho to Baal. And then when he set up its gates, he killed his youngest son Segub, placed that corpse in a ceramic jar, and buried it in the foundation of the gates, for the same reason. Joshua’s prophesy was a deliberate warning to Israel not to turn to Baal worship with which they were now familiar, and it had specific significance to Jericho which in the days of Joshua’s conquest was the first, and in that respect, the most important stage of their conquest. Where then do we place Jericho’s rebuilding? Certainly, in or after the Late Bronze age of Palestine, not the Middle Bronze age or before. And the Late Bronze of Jericho’s archaeological horizon is much affected by erosion and other damage. Conclusion Habermehl’s (2024) placement of the conquest of Jericho has merit and I believe is essentially correct. However, her time placement of the rebuilding of Jericho is illogical, incorrect, and full of misunderstanding. …. References Habermehl, Anne. 2018. “Chronology and the Gezer Connection—Solomon, Thutmose III, Shishak and Hatshepsut.” Journal of Creation 32, no. 2 (August): 83–90. Habermehl, Anne. 2024. “The Walls of Jericho: Dating Joshua’s Conquest of Canaan.” Answers Research Journal 17 (January 10): 1–8. https://answersresearchjournal.org/ archaeology/jericho-dating-joshuas-conquest-of-canaan/. Osgood, John. 2020a. “The Times of the Judges—Archaeology Exodus to Conquest.” In They Speak with one Voice: A Correlation of the Bible Record with Archaeology. Self published. Osgood, John. 2020b. “The Times of the Judges—The Archaeology 2.” In They Speak with one Voice: A Correlation of the Bible Record with Archaeology. Self-published

Monday, September 15, 2025

King David’s Hymnody impacted ancient world

by Damien F. Mackey “Psalm 104 is almost a duplicate of the Egyptian Hymn to Aten”. Facts About Religion There is an abundance of articles, and some YouTube videos, too, drawing parallels between the incredibly alike Psalm 104 of King David of Israel and pharaoh Akhnaton’s (Akhenaten’s) Hymn to the Aton (Aten). The following example neatly tabulates comparisons between these ancient texts: https://factsaboutreligion.wordpress.com/2014/07/31/psalm-104-is-almost-a-duplicate-of-the-egyptian-hymn-to-aten/ Psalm 104 is almost a duplicate of the Egyptian Hymn to Aten. On the wall of a 14th century BCE tomb in Egypt archaeologists found a beautiful hymn to the god Aten. What is really strange is that the Pharaoh Akhenaten (1352-1336) who lived in an era when everyone believed in many gods, chose to believe in only one, Aten. In fact, many scholars have argued that Pharaoh Akhenaten is the earliest documented example of a monotheist in history, though others argue that he was a henotheist (thought many gods existed, but chose to worship only one.) What’s really curious about the Great Hymn to the Aten is that it closely mirrors Psalm 104 in the Hebrew Bible as a song of praise to the creator, though written hundreds of years before. Biblical scholars and historians disagree as to whether these two hymns are actually related by way of influencing one another, or whether both were independently written. In any case, the similarities are fascinating. A logical conclusion could be that King David (c. 1000 BC) was indebted to Akhnaton, more than three centuries before David, for the inspiration to compose his Psalm 104. Some would put it more bluntly. It was a case of plagiarism on the part of the Bible! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tDI3cMDzqEY Biblical Plagariasm? | Akhenaten’s Hymn to Aten Vs. Psalm 104 | Audiobook And so we must suppose it must have been - that is, until Dr. Immanuel Velikovsky turned things upside down and inside out in his Ages in Chaos (1952) and Oedipus and Akhnaton (1960) reconstructions of ancient history, demonstrating that pharaoh Akhnaton actually belonged to the C9th BC, rather than to the C14th - necessitating now that King David could not possibly have known about Akhnaton and his Hymn, whose advents were still some centuries in the future. From this superior chronological base, Dr. Velikovsky was able most convincingly to identify a succession of Syrian (Amurru) kings approximately contemporaneous with Akhnaton and the El Amarna (EA) age, Abdi-ashirta and Aziru, with, respectively, Ben-Hadad and his successor Hazael – two mighty Syrian kings well known from the Old Testament. This was an aspect of Dr. Velikovsky’s challenging revision that was very well received. Already, his new revision (written far earlier than today’s so-called New Chronology), was proving itself to be fruitful. See my recent article: An accurate revision of history is a ‘tree’ bearing ample fruit (5) An accurate revision of history is a 'tree' bearing ample fruit And it doesn’t stop there. I, building on this far preferable chronology for Akhnaton and the El Amarna (EA) period, have been able to show that Dr. Velikovsky’s Aziru/Hazael composite was the same ruler as the Syrian ‘condottiere’, Arsa (Irsu)/Aziru, of the Great Harris Papyrus, who invaded Egypt and who overthrew the gods there. AI Overview “The "Arsa (Irsu)" or Aziru mentioned in the Great Harris Papyrus is a Syrian who took control of Egypt and its gods …”. Dr. Velikovsky had really missed a trick here. From there, it not such a great step to identify the foreign invader, Aziru/Hazael/Arsa, as pharaoh Akhnaton himself who so greatly undermined the national Egyptian gods. And, as one will find upon reading my article: Akhnaton’s Theophany (5) Akhnaton's Theophany the new chronology cuts even deeper yet, into the Bible, fully accounting for Akhnaton’s celebrated monotheism – for monotheism (not henotheism, or something else) indeed it was. With EA re-located now to the C9th BC, then the United Kingdom of Israel (Saul, David and Solomon, c. 1000 BC) could be estimated by Dr. Velikovsky to have corresponded in time with the rise of the magnificent Eighteenth Dynasty of Egypt (c. C16th BC, conventional dating) – in whose later stages we encounter Akhnaton. Relevant for this article is Dr. Velikovsky’s establishing of twin pillars of revision: Hatshepsut as the biblical “Queen Sheba” and pharaoh Thutmose III as the biblical “Shishak king of Egypt”, who despoiled the Temple of Yahweh in Jerusalem shortly after King Solomon had passed away. These twin identifications have had to undergo a rocky ground-breaking of trial and error, however, before they could be securely established as pillars of revision. For Dr. Velikovsky, an intuitive genius who could arrive at right identifications, often took quite wrong paths, adopting spurious methodologies and archaeologies, to get there. Quite the opposite of some of his critics, who, fussing over and analysing minute details, and belabouring the reader with endless charts and numbers, hardly ever seem to arrive at any satisfactory conclusions. For my same conclusions as Dr. Velikovsky in these two instances, but with significantly different arguments, see e.g., for “Sheba”: The vicissitudinous life of Solomon’s pulchritudinous wife (8) The vicissitudinous life of Solomon's pulchritudinous wife and: The Queen of Beer(sheba) (8) The Queen of Beer(sheba) While, for “Shishak”, see: Yehem near Aruna - Thutmose III’s march on Jerusalem (8) Yehem near Aruna - Thutmose III's march on Jerusalem That background sets us up, now, to consider Davidic (Solomonic) and biblical influence in the inscriptions of Hatshepsut, who had grown up as a princess in Israel. In my article: Solomon and Sheba (8) Solomon and Sheba I gave the following examples in which biblical wisdom can be glimpsed amidst the stiff and formulaïc Egyptian inscriptions: …. Scriptural Influence (i) An Image from Genesis After Hatshepsut had completed her Punt expedition, she gathered her nobles and proclaimed the great things she had done. Senenmut and Nehesi had places of honour. Hatshepsut reminded them of Amon's oracle commanding her to ‘... establish for him a Punt in his house, to plant the trees of God's Land beside his temple in his garden, according as he commanded’ …. At the conclusion of her speech there is further scriptural image ‘I have made for [Amon-Ra] a Punt in his garden at Thebes ... it is big enough for him to walk about in’; Baikie … noted that this is ‘a phrase which seems to take one back to the Book of Genesis and its picture of God walking in the Garden of Eden in the cool of the evening’. This inscription speaks of Amon-Ra's love for Hatshepsut in terms almost identical to those used by the Queen of Sheba about the God of Israel's love for Solomon and his nation. Compare the italicised parts of Hatshepsut's ‘... according to the command of ... Amon ... in order to bring for him the marvels of every country, because he so much loves the King of ... Egypt, Maatkara [i.e. Hatshepsut], for his father Amen-Ra, Lord of Heaven, Lord of Earth, more than the other kings who have been in this land for ever ...’ …. with the italicised words in a song of praise spoken to Solomon by the Queen of Sheba ‘Blessed be the Lord your God, who has delighted in you and set you on the throne as king for the Lord your God! Because your God loved Israel and would establish them for ever ...’ (II Chronicles 98) …. (ii) An Image from the Psalms When Hatshepsut's commemorative obelisks were com¬pleted, she had the usual formal words inscribed on them. However, Baikie states that …: ‘The base inscriptions ... are of more importance, chiefly because they again strike that personal note which is so seldom heard from these ancient records, and give us an actual glimpse into the mind and the heart of a great woman. I do not think that it is fanciful to see in these utterances the expression of something very like a genuine piety struggling to find expression underneath all the customary verbiage of the Egyptian monumental formulae’. In language that ‘might have come straight out of the Book Psalms’, the queen continues, ‘I did it under [Amon-Ra's] command; it was he who led me. I conceived no works without his doing .... I slept not because of his temple; I erred not from that which he commanded. ... I entered into the affairs of his heart. I turned not my back on the City of the All-Lord; but turned to it the face. I know that Karnak is God's dwelling upon earth; ... the Place of his Heart; Which wears his beauty ...’. Baikie continues, unaware that it really was the Psalms and the sapiential words of David and Solomon, that had influenced Hatshepsut's prayer: ‘The sleepless eagerness of the queen for the glory of the temple of her god, and her assurance of the unspeakable sanctity of Karnak as the divine dwelling-place, find expression in almost the very words which the Psalmist used to express his ... duty towards the habitation of the God of Israel, and his certainty of Zion's sanctity as the abiding-place of Jehovah. ‘Surely I will not come into the tabernacle of my house, nor go up into my bed; I will not give sleep to mine eyes, or slumber to mine eyelids. Until I find out a place for the Lord, an habitation for the mighty God of Jacob. - For the Lord hath chosen Zion; he hath desired it for his habitation. This is my rest for ever; here will I dwell; for I have desired it’.’ (iii) An Image from Proverbs In another related verse of the Punt reliefs about Amon-Ra leading the expedition to ‘the Myrrh-terraces ... a glorious region of God's Land’, the god speaks of creating the fabled Land of Punt in playful terms reminiscent of Solomon's words about Wisdom's playful rôle in the work of Creation (Proverbs 8:12, 30-31). In the Egyptian version there is also reference to Hathor, the personification of wisdom …: ‘... it is indeed a place of delight. I have made it for myself, in order to divert my heart, together with ... Hathor ... mistress of Punt …’. Interestingly, the original rôles of Hathor and Isis in the Heliopolitan ‘theology’ were similar to those of Moses's sister and mother (the god Horus reminding of Moses). Grimal … says ‘Isis hid Horus in the marshes of the Delta ... with the help of the goddess Hathor, the wet-nurse in the form of a cow. The child grew up ...’. In The Queen of Sheba - Hatshepsut, I had compared this Egyptian account with the action of Moses's mother and sister in Exodus 2:3-4, 7, 10. (iv) Images from the Song of Songs In the weighing scene of the goods acquired from Punt (i.e. Lebanon), Hatshepsut boasts ….: ‘[Her] Majesty [herself] is acting with her two hands, the best of myrrh is upon all her limbs, her fragrance is divine dew, her odour is mingled with that of Punt, her skin is gilded with electrum, shining as do the stars in the midst of the festival-hall, before the whole land’. Compare this with verses from King Solomon's love poem, Song of Songs (also called the Song of Solomon), e.g. ‘My hands dripped with myrrh, my fingers with liquid myrrh; Sweeter your love than wine, the scent of your perfume than any spice; Your lips drip honey, and the scent of your robes is like the scent of Lebanon’ (4:10-11; 55). (cf. 4:6, 14; 5:1, 5). [Hyam] Maccoby … went so far as to suggest that the Song of Songs was written by Solomon for the Queen of Sheba/Hatshepsut. Clearly, the poem is written in the context of marriage (e.g. 3:11). We read, partly following Maccoby …: l. ‘To a mare among Pharaoh's cavalry would 1 compare you, my darling’ (1:9). This reference to Egypt is strange for an Israelite girl, but natural if the beloved was an Egyptian. 2. ‘Black am I but beautiful, O daughters of Jerusalem, like the tents of Qedar, like the curtains of Solomon. Do not gaze at me because I am swarthy, because the sun has blackened me’ (16). A darker complexion would not be surprising in an Egyptian woman. 3. Perhaps the sentence ‘Who is she that cometh out of the wilderness ... perfumed with myrrh and frankincense, with all the fragrant powders of the merchant?’ (3:6), refers to the visit by the Queen of Sheba, who brought a great store of perfumes. She gave Solomon ‘a very great store of spices ... there came no more such abundance of spices as these which the Queen of Sheba gave to King Solomon’ (I Kings 10:10). 4. ‘My mother's sons were angry with me. They made me the keeper of the vineyards, but mine own vineyard I have not kept’ (1:6). It is a puzzle that the female here is represented as a humble vineyard-watcher but elsewhere she appears as a great lady. Maybe here she is speaking metaphorically about her country (and her native reli¬gion?) as a ‘vineyard’? The anger of her ‘brothers’ would be understandable, perhaps, if she were a princess of Egypt. Her involvement with Solomon would have unwelcome politi-cal and religious implications. 5. ‘O that you were as my brother ... I would lead you and bring you to my mother's house’ (8:1-2). She perhaps regrets that Solomon is not an Egyptian, who could live permanently with her. What has been presented here probably represents only a very small portion of Israel’s wisdom influence upon the ancient nations. The only other theme that I shall touch on here, most relevant to King David of Israel, is the notion of the king as shepherd. I have already written something about this in my article: Shepherd King contemporaries of King David (10) Shepherd King contemporaries of King David And compare this one: “Prince Rim-Sîn, you are the shepherd, the desire of his heart”, with the shepherd David’s being “a man after my own heart” (Acts 13:22). CONTEMPORARY SHEPHERD KINGS One could describe David’s life during his service to King Saul, as, ‘never a dull moment’. King Saul was indeed a mercurial character, totally unpredictable. Naturally, Samuel had been nervous about visiting Jesse of Bethlehem for the purpose of anointing one of his sons to the kingship (I Samuel 16:1-2): The LORD said to Samuel, ‘How long will you mourn for Saul, since I have rejected him as king over Israel? Fill your horn with oil and be on your way; I am sending you to Jesse of Bethlehem. I have chosen one of his sons to be king’. But Samuel said, ‘How can I go? If Saul hears about it, he will kill me’. Even the wise Samuel had been inclined to judge by appearances (“height”) the worth of Jesse’s sons (v. 6): “When they arrived, Samuel saw Eliab and thought, ‘Surely the LORD’s anointed stands here before the LORD’.” But, in an interesting glimpse into the Lord’s thinking, we then read (v. 7): “But the LORD said to Samuel, ‘Do not consider his appearance or his height, for I have rejected him. The LORD does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the LORD looks at the heart’.” Had not Saul himself, who would so miserably fail as king, been a man of the most striking height and appearance (I Samuel 9:2): “Kish had a son named Saul, as handsome a young man as could be found anywhere in Israel, and he was a head taller than anyone else”? David, the youngest of Jesse’s eight sons, was not even present (v. 11): “‘There is still the youngest’, Jesse answered. ‘He is tending the sheep’.” It is this characteristic that would mark David’s kingship, ‘tending his sheep’. He was, like Jesus Christ, a true “Shepherd King”, modelling himself upon “the Lord [who was his] Shepherd” (Psalm 22, Douay). Kings at this time (revised) came to describe themselves from this time onwards as Shepherds. For example (Hammurabi Stele): I, Hammurabi, the shepherd, have gathered abundance and plenty, have stormed the four quarters of the world, have magnified the fame of Babylon, and have elated the mind of Marduk my lord. And compare this one: “Prince Rim-Sîn, you are the shepherd, the desire of his heart”, with the shepherd David’s being “a man after my own heart” (Acts 13:22). Rim-Sin, king of Larsa, was an older contemporary of Hammurabi of Babylon. Rim-sin’s prayerful sentiments can be very David-like – even quasi-monotheistic: “-7......, who is fitted for holy lustration rites, Rim-Sîn, purification priest of An, who is fitted for pure prayers rites, whom you summoned from the holy womb ......, has been elevated to lordship over the Land; he has been installed as shepherd over the black-headed. The staff which strengthens the Land has been placed in his hand. The shepherd's crook which guides the living people has been attached at his side. As he steps forward before you, he is lavishly supplied with everything that he offers with his pure hands. 8-20Your attentive youth, your beloved king, the good shepherd Rìm-Sîn, who determines what should be brought as offerings for his life, joyfully pours out offerings for you in the holy royal cultic locations which are perfect for the cultic vessels: sweet-smelling milk and grain, rich produce of the Land, riches of the meadows, unending abundance, alcoholic drink, glistening wine, very sweet emmer beer fermented with pure substances, pure ...... powerful beer made doubly strong with wine, a drink for your lordship; double-strength beer, superior beer, befitting your holy hands, pale honey exported from the mountains, which you have specifically requested, butter from holy cows, ghee as is proper for you as prince; pressed oil, best oil of the first pressing, and yellow cream, the pride of the cow-pen, for the holy abode of your godhead. 21-26Accept from him with your joyful heart pure food to eat as food, and pure water to drink as water: offerings made for you. Grant his prayer: you are indeed respected. When he humbly speaks fair words to you, speak so that he may live. Guide him correctly at the holy lordly cultic locations, at the august lordly cultic locations. Greet him as he comes to perform his cultic functions. 27-37May his kingship exist forever in your presence. May he be the first of the Land, called (?) lord and prince. Following your commands he shall be as unshakeable as heaven and earth; may he be ...... over the numerous people. May the mother goddesses among the gods attend to his utterances; may they sit in silence before that which he says, and bring restorative life. May he create heart's joy for the population, and be the good provider for their days. May the terrifying splendour that he wears cover like a heavy raincloud the king who is hated by him. May all the best what he has be brought here as their offerings. 38-52The good shepherd Rim-Sîn looks to you as to his personal god. Grant him ...... a life that he loves, and bestow joy on him. May you renew it like the daylight. As he prays to you, attend to his ....... When he speaks most fair words to you, sustain his life power for him. May he be respected ......, and have no rivals. As he makes supplication to you, make his days long. In the ...... of life, ...... the power of kingship. May his correct words be ever ....... May he create heart's joy in his ....... ...... make the restorative ...... rest upon him, the lion of lordship. When he beseeches you, let his exterior (?) ...... shine. Give him ...... life ....... May you bring ...... for his life with your holy words. Hear him favourably as he lifts his hands in prayer, and decide a good destiny for him. 53-69As his life ......, so may it delight his land. Cast the four quarters at his feet, and let him be their ruler. Reclining in meadows in his own land, may he pass his days joyously with you ....... In the palace, lengthen the days and reign of Rim-Sîn, your compliant king who is there for you; whose name you, Acimbabbar, have named, ...... life. ...... the august good headdress. ...... due praise for his life. ...... the throne, and may the land be safe. May satisfaction and joy fill his heart. May ...... be good for his ....... Place in his hand the sceptre of justice; may the numerous people be bound (?) to it. Shining brightly, the constant ...... in his ....... Confer on him the benefit of months of delight and joy, and bestow on him numerous years as infinite in number as the stars in the lapis-lazuli coloured heavens. In his kingship may he enjoy a happy reign forever. 70-85May you preserve the king, the good provider. May you preserve Rim-Sîn, the good provider. May his reign be a source of delight to you. Lengthen the days of his life, and give him kingship over the restored land. For him gladden the heart of the land, for him make the roads of the land passable. For him make the Land speak with a single voice. May you preserve alive Rim-Sîn, your shepherd with the compliant heart. May his canals bring water for him, and may barley grow for him in the fields. May the orchards and gardens bring forth syrup and wine for him, and may the marshes deliver fish and fowl for him in abundance. May the cattle-pens and sheepfolds teem with animals, and may rain from the heavens, whose waters are sporadic, be regular for him. May the palace be filled with long life. O Rim-Sîn, you are my king!” Compare, for example, King David’s Psalm 60 (Douay), otherwise Psalm 61:6-7: ‘Increase the days of the king’s life, his years for many generations. May he be enthroned in God’s presence forever; appoint your love and faithfulness to protect him’. According to Timothy S. Laniak (Shepherds After My Own Heart: Pastoral Traditions and Leadership in the Bible, p. 63): “By the beginning of the second millennium BC [sic] Akkadian and Amorite kings were using conventional shepherd language to describe themselves”. When David - young, but mature beyond his years - indignant at the mockery being publicly and loudly uttered by the Gath-ite champion, Goliath - ‘defying the armies of the living God’ - was told by King Saul that he was not experienced enough to fight against the Philistine, he will apprise the king of the extreme dangers that he had already faced as a shepherd: ‘When a lion or a bear came and carried off a sheep from the flock, I went after it …’. Here follows David’s exchange on this occasion with King Saul (I Samuel 17:32-37): David said to Saul, ‘Let no one lose heart on account of this Philistine; your servant will go and fight him’. Saul replied, ‘You are not able to go out against this Philistine and fight him; you are only a young man, and he has been a warrior from his youth’. But David said to Saul, ‘Your servant has been keeping his father’s sheep. When a lion or a bear came and carried off a sheep from the flock, I went after it, struck it and rescued the sheep from its mouth. When it turned on me, I seized it by its hair, struck it and killed it. Your servant has killed both the lion and the bear; this uncircumcised Philistine will be like one of them, because he has defied the armies of the living God. The LORD who rescued me from the paw of the lion and the paw of the bear will rescue me from the hand of this Philistine’. Saul said to David, ‘Go, and the LORD be with you’. Young David had been taking supplies from his father Jesse back to his three oldest brothers, and then returning “to tend his father’s sheep at Bethlehem” (vv. 14-19). Now these were the very three sons, the “firstborn was Eliab; the second, Abinadab; and the third, Shammah”, whom Samuel had first considered for the anointing (I Samuel 16:6-9). Yet here they were frozen almost to a standstill in the face of the angry Goliath (“all the Israelites were dismayed and terrified”), while David, the youngest of them, was aflame with indignation. It is a famous story (17:1-11): Now the Philistines gathered their forces for war and assembled at Sokoh in Judah. They pitched camp at Ephes Dammim, between Sokoh and Azekah. Saul and the Israelites assembled and camped in the Valley of Elah and drew up their battle line to meet the Philistines. The Philistines occupied one hill and the Israelites another, with the valley between them. A champion named Goliath, who was from Gath, came out of the Philistine camp. His height was six cubits and a span. He had a bronze helmet on his head and wore a coat of scale armor of bronze weighing five thousand shekels; on his legs he wore bronze greaves, and a bronze javelin was slung on his back. His spear shaft was like a weaver’s rod, and its iron point weighed six hundred shekels. His shield bearer went ahead of him. Goliath stood and shouted to the ranks of Israel, ‘Why do you come out and line up for battle? Am I not a Philistine, and are you not the servants of Saul? Choose a man and have him come down to me. If he is able to fight and kill me, we will become your subjects; but if I overcome him and kill him, you will become our subjects and serve us’. Then the Philistine said, ‘This day I defy the armies of Israel! Give me a man and let us fight each other’. On hearing the Philistine’s words, Saul and all the Israelites were dismayed and terrified. Eliab, the oldest of Jesse’s boys, the one upon whom Samuel had first fastened, would severely reprimand his youngest brother for intruding into the army’s affairs, also implying that David may have been neglecting their father’s sheep. But we had already been told that David, who was only obeying his father’s instructions, anyway, had “left the flock in the care of a shepherd”. Here follows the feisty David’s exchanges with the Israelite soldiers and with Eliab (vv. 20-31): Early in the morning David left the flock in the care of a shepherd, loaded up and set out, as Jesse had directed. He reached the camp as the army was going out to its battle positions, shouting the war cry. Israel and the Philistines were drawing up their lines facing each other. David left his things with the keeper of supplies, ran to the battle lines and asked his brothers how they were. As he was talking with them, Goliath, the Philistine champion from Gath, stepped out from his lines and shouted his usual defiance, and David heard it. Whenever the Israelites saw the man, they all fled from him in great fear. Now the Israelites had been saying, ‘Do you see how this man keeps coming out? He comes out to defy Israel. The king will give great wealth to the man who kills him. He will also give him his daughter in marriage and will exempt his family from taxes in Israel’. David asked the men standing near him, ‘What will be done for the man who kills this Philistine and removes this disgrace from Israel? Who is this uncircumcised Philistine that he should defy the armies of the living God?’ They repeated to him what they had been saying and told him, ‘This is what will be done for the man who kills him’. When Eliab, David’s oldest brother, heard him speaking with the men, he burned with anger at him and asked, ‘Why have you come down here? And with whom did you leave those few sheep in the wilderness? I know how conceited you are and how wicked your heart is; you came down only to watch the battle’. ‘Now what have I done?’ said David. ‘Can’t I even speak?’ He then turned away to someone else and brought up the same matter, and the men answered him as before. What David said was overheard and reported to Saul, and Saul sent for him. It has been said: “One man’s meat is another man’s poison”. King Saul’s armour, which the huge Benjaminite wore easily, was nothing but cumbersome to the smaller man, David. To use another saying, it fell ‘all over him like a cheap suit’. Vv. 38-39: Then Saul dressed David in his own tunic. He put a coat of armor on him and a bronze helmet on his head. David fastened on his sword over the tunic and tried walking around, because he was not used to them. ‘I cannot go in these’, he said to Saul, ‘because I am not used to them’ So he took them off”. Then, it is back to his shepherding experience (v. 40): “Then he took his staff in his hand, chose five smooth stones from the stream, put them in the pouch of his shepherd’s bag and, with his sling in his hand, approached the Philistine”. Christians can regard David’s “five smooth stones”, symbolically, as the five wounds of Christ, and again, with the “sling”, as the five-decade Rosary. Thus Frits Albers introduced his book, “… five smooth stones …” (1998).

Tuesday, August 12, 2025

Horrible Histories: Ludicrous Luwians

by Damien F. Mackey My guess (and that is all it is at this early stage) is that the Luwians, or Hurrians, were one of those Philistine enclaves in other peoples’ lands. A reader, properly appreciating the ramifications of a radically revised Anatolian geography, as laid out in my article: Search for the Median empire (3) Search for the Median empire has well anticipated the need for further identifications: Dear Damien, relocation of Media to central&south Anatolia would place it smack in Luwite territory. Take it from there. …. My response: The Luwians, it seems to me … are one of those languages-without-a-people sorts of scenarios. Like the Hurrians. Now, given Brock Heathcotte’s letter w(a) and r interchange - thus Assuwa becomes Assyria: Mitanni and Urartu the same place: Heathcotte (3) Mitanni and Urartu the same place: Heathcotte - and given the variation of the first consonant, thus the Luwians were also called Nuwians, then it is not hard to make that actual connection, Luwian = Hurrian: NLuw(r)ian = Hur(r)ian. But who were the Hurrians? My guess (and that is all it is at this early stage) is that the Luwians, or Hurrians, were one of those Philistine enclaves in other peoples’ lands. Another of the many guises of the Philistines (or related peoples): An early study of Philistine origins (4) An early study of Philistine origins